Two Rivers Coop
Cash Bids
Text Alerts
Market Data
News & Commentary
Weather
|
RBC, BMO, TD: Who Wins the Canadian Big Five Banks’ Financial Face Off and Net-Zero Race?![]() The Canadian banking sector is under pressure to balance financial growth with sustainability. The Big Five banks of the country - Royal Bank of Canada (RBC), Bank of Montreal (BMO), Bank of Nova Scotia (Scotiabank), TD Bank, and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC) - have all reported their latest earnings while advancing their climate commitments. The Big Five banks' financial results reflect the strength of the Canadian economy, while their sustainability and net-zero initiatives show how committed they're to reducing carbon emissions. But how do these Canadian banks compare? Let’s dive into their latest earnings and see who is leading the charge toward a greener future. Financial Performance: A Competitive LandscapeRoyal Bank of Canada (RBC): Record Earnings with Strong PerformanceRBC reported a net income of CAD 5.13 billion in Q1 2025, up from CAD 3.52 billion in Q1 2024. Adjusted earnings per share (EPS) stood at CAD 3.62, surpassing analyst expectations of CAD 3.24.
RBC's financial performance was bolstered by a strong wealth management division, which saw a 48% increase in income, and robust capital markets earnings. The acquisition of HSBC Bank Canada contributed an additional CAD 214 million to net income. Bank of Montreal (BMO): Solid Growth Amid Economic ChallengesBMO reported a net income of CAD 2.14 billion in Q1 2025, up from CAD 1.29 billion in Q1 2024. Adjusted earnings per share (EPS) stood at CAD 3.04, surpassing analyst expectations of CAD 2.41.
BMO’s financial performance was strong despite higher credit provisions. Its capital markets division contributed significantly, with a 45% increase in adjusted net income, reaching CAD 591 million. Bank of Nova Scotia (Scotiabank): Facing Margin PressureScotiabank’s Q1 2025 net income stood at CAD 2.02 billion, slightly lower than CAD 2.12 billion in Q1 2024. Adjusted EPS was CAD 1.68, missing expectations of CAD 1.70.
While Scotiabank saw modest revenue growth, higher loan loss provisions and lower NIMs affected profitability. The bank’s Latin American operations performed well, helping offset domestic weakness. TD Bank: Strong Performance Despite Loan LossesTD Bank announced a net income of CAD 2.79 billion in Q1 2025, a slight decline from CAD 2.82 billion in Q1 2024. Adjusted EPS was CAD 1.55, remaining flat year-over-year.
TD’s performance was driven by strong deposit growth and capital markets revenue. However, increased provisions for credit losses reflect potential economic headwinds. CIBC: Higher Earnings But Growing Risks CIBC posted a Q1 2025 net income of CAD 2.18 billion, up from CAD 1.73 billion in Q1 2024. Adjusted EPS was CAD 2.20, above the consensus estimate of CAD 1.81.
CIBC’s earnings growth was supported by strong loan and deposit growth. Its capital markets unit saw a 19% increase in net income, reaching CAD 619 million. However, rising provisions for bad loans signal caution. Carbon Emission Reductions and Sustainability Race: Who’s Leading?As these Big Five Canadian banks are going after profits, they, too, are under pressure to go after their sustainable and net-zero goals. Let's see what they're doing to hit their climate goals. Royal Bank of Canada (RBC): Advancing Towards Net ZeroRBC has pledged to achieve net-zero emissions in its operations and financed emissions by 2050. The bank is aligning its lending and investment activities with global climate targets, focusing on energy efficiency, sustainable finance, and emissions reductions. RBC’s GHG emissions totaled 119,802 metric tons of CO₂e in 2023, reflecting a steady decline from previous years. The bank has committed CAD 500 billion in sustainable finance by 2025.
Source: RBC Climate Report As of 2023, RBC has allocated CAD 393 billion in sustainable finance, making progress toward its CAD 500 billion target by 2025.
Source: RBC Climate Report The most valuable bank in Canada also used carbon offsets as part of its strategy to neutralize its operational footprint. Key emission reduction initiatives are:
RBC remains committed to climate risk management and improving transparency in its sustainability disclosures. The bank continues to refine its financed emissions tracking and collaborates with businesses to meet shared net-zero goals. Bank of Montreal (BMO): Charging its Net-Zero AmbitionsBMO has committed to achieving net-zero emissions in its operations by 2050. The bank has been carbon-neutral in its operations since 2010 and aims to cut its Scope 1 and 2 emissions by 30% by 2030 (from a 2019 baseline). The bank has achieved this by:
In 2023, the bank’s total greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions stood at 101,960 metric tons CO₂e, down 12% from 2022 levels. The bank retired 45,918 tCO₂e of carbon credits in the same year as part of its emission reduction strategies.
Source: BMO Climate Report Major climate actions include:
BMO has pledged CAD 300 billion in sustainable financing and has surpassed this with CAD 330 billion issued as of 2023. The giant financier aims to support businesses transitioning to a low-carbon economy. In 2023, the bank expanded its emissions tracking for lending portfolios, including commercial real estate, and continues to refine its sustainability-linked lending framework. Bank of Nova Scotia (Scotiabank): Carbon Intensity ReductionScotiabank aims for net-zero financed emissions by 2050 and a 40% reduction in operational emissions by 2030. In 2023, its operational carbon emissions were 110,000 metric tons CO₂e, down 9% year-over-year.
Source: Scotiabank Report The Canadian bank has reduced energy consumption in branches and offices by 25% as part of its net-zero efforts. It has also financed low-carbon initiatives in Latin America Scotiabank has set a target of providing CAD 350 billion in climate-related financing by 2030. In 2023, the bank provided CAD 36 billion toward this goal, bringing its cumulative total to CAD 132 billion since 2018. Key climate initiatives include:
The bank also continues to reduce its own operational emissions by securing emissions-free electricity, implementing energy efficiency programs, and integrating climate risk assessments into its lending strategy. TD Bank: Leading in Sustainable Finance and DecarbonizationTD Bank has the most aggressive green finance strategy among the four banks. It has pledged CAD 500 billion in sustainable and decarbonization finance by 2030, with nearly CAD 70 billion allocated in 2023 alone. TD has emitted a total of 117,317 metric tons of CO₂e in 2023, down 14% from 2022. The bank has already achieved a 28% reduction in operational Scope 1 and 2 emissions, surpassing its 2025 target of 25%.
Source: TD Bank climate report The bank has retired 85,176 verified carbon reduction and removal credits, equal to the bank’s market-based Scope 1 and 2 emissions and Scope 3 category 6 (business travel) emissions. More notably, the bank has one of the largest direct air capture (DAC) carbon credit purchases in the financial sector. It agreed to buy 27,500 metric tons of carbon removal credits over four years. Also, TD Bank has expanded its financial emissions tracking across nine high-emission sectors, including energy, automotive, and agriculture. The financier has also improved climate risk assessment tools and developed a central data repository to track emissions reduction progress across its operations and client portfolio.
Source: TD Bank climate report Other Sustainability Highlights:
CIBC: Balancing Growth and SustainabilityCIBC is committed to reducing its Scope 1 and 2 emissions and achieving net zero. In 2023, its operational emissions stood at 71,031 metric tons CO₂e, a 5% increase from 2022.
Source: CIBC Sustainability Report Per CIBC's sustainability report, the bank has set a 30% operational GHG reduction target by 2028 (compared to 2018 levels). It also aims to achieve carbon neutrality in operations by 2024. The bank is on track to meet this target through:
The bank has issued over CAD 157 billion in sustainable finance investments as of 2023. It has a target of 300 billion by 2030. CIBC helped finance sustainable infrastructure projects. This includes battery energy storage systems in the UK and big renewable energy deals. Who’s Winning the Net Zero Race?With all the sustainability initiatives and financing solutions provided by each bank, who wins the net-zero race? The chart below shows the comparison of the banks’ GHG emissions and sustainable finance progress as of 2023.
Source: Companies' Data Overall, TD Bank and RBC lead with the highest sustainable finance commitment, while BMO has surpassed its financing goal. RBC is also making significant strides in sustainable finance and net-zero initiatives, leveraging its market leadership. CIBC has made strong progress in both emissions reductions and sustainable investments. Meanwhile, Scotiabank continues expanding its climate financing but has the third-highest operational emissions among the five banks. Conclusion: Balancing Profitability with Climate CommitmentsThe five major Canadian banks continue to navigate economic headwinds while strengthening their sustainability and net-zero initiatives. While financial results varied, all banks have made progress in decarbonization efforts, sustainable finance, and emissions reductions.
As regulatory pressure and investor expectations increase, these Big Five Canadian banks will need to accelerate their climate and net-zero strategies while maintaining profitability. Future progress will depend on expanding sustainable finance, improving emissions tracking, and supporting client transitions to a low-carbon economy. For real-time insights into carbon pricing, visit our Live Carbon Pricing page. This article contains syndicated content. We have not reviewed, approved, or endorsed the content, and may receive compensation for placement of the content on this site. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.
|
|